When The Exorcist came out in 1973, this was back in the day when it was common for a movie to be shown in no more than one theater in any given city. In Houston, that was the River Oaks Theater. For six months, the lines wrapped around the block. Tales were told of people in the audience throwing up, so naturally I couldn’t wait to see it. However, my friend and I did wait until the lines finally shortened to a reasonable length, at which point we decided it was time to go. It became my favorite religious movie.
There is a scene in that movie in which Father Karras (Jason Miller) talks to Father Merrin (Max von Sydow), who has just arrived at the house where Regan (Linda Blair) is in the throes of demonic possession. Karras, who has previously admitted that he is losing his faith, has been trying to deal with Regan in terms of his knowledge of psychiatry. He says: “I think it would be helpful if I gave you some background on the different personalities Regan has manifested. So far, there seems to be three.”
Merrin interrupts him: “There’s only one.”
That was a heavy line. I naturally assumed that he was referring to Satan. At the beginning of the movie, we saw a statue of what I later learned was Pazuzu, an ancient Mesopotamian demon, but I figured that was just the Babylonian and Assyrian conception of Satan. In other words, The Exorcist presumes that Christianity is the true religion, so even if you are an atheist, you go along with that for the sake of enjoying the movie. And that means that either Satan or one of his angels has possessed Regan.
Recently, I saw Exorcist II: The Heretic. According to that movie, it actually was Pazuzu who had possessed Regan in the original. So, what does that mean, that Christianity is not the true religion after all, that the gods Marduk, Ashur, etc. are the real gods? If so, a Catholic priest would seem to be wrong for the job of exorcism, since what he believes is false.
Alternatively, if all religions are to be regarded as somehow true, in an ecumenical spirit of inclusiveness, then I suppose that all the demons of all those religions are somehow real too. In that case, I guess Satan didn’t have time to possess Regan himself, so he had to turn to some other religion and farm the job out.
In the documentary, Boorman and the Devil (2025), John Boorman says that he had previously been offered the chance to direct The Exorcist, but he turned it down: “I read the book. I was rather horrified by it. As a father of daughters, it seemed to me to be a book about torturing a child. So, I declined.” This is our first indication that Boorman was not in sympathy with the original movie.
Later, Boorman gives us a further indication of the distance he felt from the original as he comments on the negative reaction people had to Exorcist II:
It wasn’t a sequel. It was a riposte, an answer to The Exorcist. It wasn’t what they were expecting, which is a horror film. It didn’t fit. Here was a sequel, which wasn’t a sequel. Blatty, the author of the book, disowned it. There was a riot in Westwood. They were deeply disappointed. I mean, they threw things at the screen. They demanded their money back. People felt utterly cheated, angry, and all that anger and bitterness was directed at me. I made a film about goodness. And that was a film about evil.
Early in this sequel, Regan is under the care of Dr. Gene Tuskin (Louise Fletcher), who has a gadget that permits synchronized hypnosis. The way it works is that two people sit opposite each other at a table, each with an electronic headband wrapped around his or her forehead. Each headband has a wire attached to a device on a table situated between them. A strobe light is used to synchronize their brain frequencies through biofeedback. Then each person can see what is in the other person’s mind. When Dr. Tuskin sees the repressed memories of Regan’s demonic possession, she almost has a heart attack. Before she is brought out of the hypnotic state, she is told to forget what she had seen, for the sake of her own mental health.
Science fiction and the supernatural are two genres that should not be mixed. An exception can be made if the movie is a comedy, such as Ghostbusters (1984), where the title characters must contend with the demon Gozer with streams of energy produced by their proton packs. However, Exorcist II: The Heretic is a serious movie. Because it includes both science fiction and the supernatural, our ability to suspend disbelief is weakened, being pulled as it is in two different directions.
At one point in the movie, Regan asks Father Lamont (Richard Burton) if priests believe in ESP. He says that some do. Well, the answer should be that they all do, for does God not have psychic powers? He knows what is in everyone’s mind (mental telepathy); he knows what will happen in the future (precognition); he parted the Red Sea (telekinesis).
Presumably, the only meaningful question is whether there are people that have ESP. Lamont continues: “A French priest thought we’d all come together in some sort of telepathy. A kind of world mind in which everybody would share.”
Boorman explains this plot point:
…[T]he inspiration for the central concepts in the script came from the writings of a French theologian. It had this idea about Teilhard de Chardin, the French theologist, who proposed that evolution would bring people together, connecting them in the subconscious, and that this coming together of people would eventually affect the whole human race, and the whole human race would merge into oneness, which would kind of become God in a sense. And so, that piqued my interest. I started to think about it, and it was an opportunity to make a film about, really, metaphysics, and to express those metaphysical ideas in images and sound and character.
Father Lamont ties the religious notions of Teilhard to advances in science: “Father Merrin believed that, with modern research, it could happen soon. I mean the kind of research Dr. Tuskin is doing.”
As far as this movie is concerned, however, there is only one example in which one person’s being in some kind of psychic union with another has a positive result, and that is when Regan is able to get a little girl with autism to start talking. Otherwise, the result is bad. For one thing, it is because Regan has a susceptible psyche that Pazuzu was able to possess her. For another, a possessed woman in Latin America with the power to heal the sick ends up burning to death. We have already seen how Dr. Tuskin suffered ill effects from being in synchronized hypnosis with Regan. Finally, while Lamont is in Africa looking for some character named Kokumo (James Earl Jones), who had once been possessed by Pazuzu, Regan and some other hoofers are tapdancing to “Lullaby of Broadway.” When Lamont tells some of the natives, “I flew with Pazuzu in a trance,” they begin stoning him. Because Lamont has some kind of psychic connection with Regan, every time he is hit with a stone, Regan suffers physically as well, to the point that she careens off the stage.
Ultimately, the idea of a unity of consciousness is exemplified by locusts. According to Kokumo, who is now a scientist:
The key factor is the brushing of the wings. When it is dry, the grasshoppers go their own way, happy individuals. When a heavy rain hatches them in large numbers, they crowd together. Their wings brush against each other. The agitation transforms them…. Most importantly, the brushing of the wings changes their personality. They become a destructive, voracious, marauding swarm, with a single mind. A locust mind, if you will. The evil swarm sweeps over the earth, possessing all that it touches. Evil breeding evil by contact.
However, Kokumo says there is hope for the future with the help of science:
Look at this young female. She has been evolved to resist the brushing of the wings. At least, that is our hope. We like to call her the Good Locust. Her children will be our agents in the swarm, breaking the chain reaction, remaining forever happy-go-lucky grasshoppers.
But that implies that the good locusts of the future will not become part of that single locust mind.
From this it would seem to follow that we will all be better off if we remain individuals rather than become part of one big collective mind, contradicting the very metaphysics that Boorman said was the basis for this movie.
For most of us, the loss of privacy implied by all that psychic unity would be dreadful. All efforts to be polite would fail, for offensive thoughts about someone would immediately be communicated to him. Worse yet, a person you dislike would not be someone you could simply avoid, for his mind would now be part of your mind.
Teilhard spoke of the merging of consciousness into a single mind as happening by way of evolution. Actually, it might be the other way around. Once upon a time, most people were psychic. When they all knew what they thought of one another, their hearts were filled with hatred, and they slaughtered one another without mercy. In the end, only those who did not have ESP survived, for they were able to conceal their innermost thoughts. But that is whimsical.
As cited above, Boorman said, “I made a film about goodness.” You would have to believe in goodness in a big way if you dream of a world in which everyone would be in touch with everyone else through some kind of mind-meld process. “But,” as Father Lamont noted, “if it happens before we’re ready, we may find ourselves pointing in the wrong direction, toward Satan.”
That’s for sure!
One thought on “Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977)”